When you get to the market, youll realize that the golf iron industry is saturated. The centre of gravity in hybrid irons is far lower and deeper than a typical cavity-back iron. The fact that five of our eight Category 3 irons are forged tells the story of who theyre aimed at. The turf interaction for me is much better with i210 and they fly much more consistently than the jacked-up G410s did. I keep coming back to a split set of ZX5's and ZX7's. Theyre a great looking club. The Ping G410 irons will run you about $750 for a brand new standard set. Of course the head size helps in this department but it was obvious during our testing that the elastomer insert also makes significantly more face contact space for the player. Golfers who arent afraid to admit that their game needs as much help as they can get their hands on is a reasonable rule of thumb here. Ping i525 Irons Category: Players Distance Irons Ping i210 Irons Category: Player's Irons Todays Golfertest verdictSince their launch in 2018, the i210s have been Pings most popular tour iron. They are easy to launch high and long. Required fields are marked *, document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "a2b2440be1ab79640ba509c3d121083a" );document.getElementById("a39d109f68").setAttribute( "id", "comment" );Comment *. I like them so much that I bought a set of i200s for a practice/backup bag. Just got the 425s inand took some comparison pictures for. For looks and feel, i210 won, but if I'm going for PING this year it will be G425. Brands invest huge sums developing new technology in this area. GolfWRX_Spotted posted a topic in Tour and Pre-Release Equipment, Monday at 09:57 PM, GolfWRX posted a topic in Tour and Pre-Release Equipment, January 10, GolfWRX_Spotted posted a topic in Tour and Pre-Release Equipment, January 3, GolfWRX_Spotted posted a topic in PGA WITB and Tournament Pics, December 15, 2022, GolfWRX_Spotted posted a topic in PGA WITB and Tournament Pics, December 7, 2022, By In many instances, the clubhead size in this category will be a little larger to inspire more confidence at address. Previous G irons in my eyes were big clunky irons. We created an indoor test lab atKeele Golf Centreto ensure a controlled environment. Very often, Category 3 and Category 3.5 irons end up in the hands of improving golfers, but they subtly target different players, hence why Callaway make both an Apex 19 (forged and in Category 3) and a Mavrik (cast and in Category 3.5). With every major 2022 iron model now available in the shops, the time felt right to show how each brands iron range compares when they go head-to-head. However, if you are in need of slightly more forgiveness, we would recommend the Ping i210 irons. Theres a very good reason why Players Distance irons (forgiveness Category 2.5) have become so popular over the last few years. Equal to the i210 although 3 degrees stronger. 2022 Amazon Associates Program. The Ping i525s play hot and fast. We did notice that the 3 and 4 irons of the Ping i210 set played longer than those of the i59 set by an average of 6 yards. Before we came to any conclusions, we analysed the data for each club tested; on distance, spin rates, forgiveness. Historically, super game-improver models have big chunky heads, thick toplines and even wider soles. Matt, 70 year old 6 handicapper looking for new irons. But the machined face grooves are really where a lot of the gap between these irons is made up. That's a real problem for me, so I went with i210. Launch Monitor Data: How the Ping irons compared. This, coupled with the wide and cascading sole allows a quality ball launch angle. In fact, if we had to describe the performance and the feel of these irons with just one adjective, it would certainly be smooth.. Another difference between these two iron sets is strength of loft. Both of these club sets are game improvement. I can hit a 7 iron and not know from the strike ifthe ball is going 175yards or 145 yards. Category High-handicap | Forgiveness rating 4/5 | Handicap range 28 and below | Construction Hollow body (17-4 stainless steel), with maraging steel face | 7-iron loft 29.5. * MD4 54/10 S-Grind replacedMD3 54/12 W-Grind. A little extra offset in the long irons helps flight longer approaches a little more easily at reasonable speeds. These hollow boyd irons live up to their reputation and a worth a look for any superior ball strikers looking for a blend of ditance, feel and forgiveness without giving the full soft feel of a real players iron like the i59. They have similar body shapes and styles, are aimed at the same, high-level players, and produce a similar performance. Upload or insert images from URL. Mizuno JPX 921 Forged Irons The irons incorporate two weights, a visible screw at the front of the clubhead and a weight in the hosel. The i59s combine a forged carbon steel body with a 17-4 stainless steel face. Category 3 models are a wolf in sheeps clothing. This will suit beginners and high handicappers but also any mid to low handicappers who struggle to hit their irons consistently while it wont suit advanced strikers who want to work the ball a bit more with a draw or a fade. But thats not really who they are made for anyway. (i500 were not to my taste.). They also have a multi material badge filling in the cavity at the back to dampen any vibrations on mishits. The first thing to notice about the Ping i525 is the sleek looking players shape at address while the soles are still thick enough to offer distance and a towering ball flight. Clubs Irons G425 G425 The metal-wood-style, variable-thickness face and internal geometry increase ball speed and flexing for launching shots higher and further with stopping power to hold greens. The Taylormade P790's will set you back nearly $1,500 while you can score a set of Ping G425 irons for around $900. Waiting on my set, which is due to be delivered today! Fair enough, personally having played both ping i210 and 919 tour, I think you would be much better suited in the i210 than the g425. The Ping i525 irons have forged, maraging steel faces and 17-4 stainless steel bodies. With that being said the CG is lower and there is an extra degree of bounce so you can still the ball in the air easily. For some that means lovely turf interaction, but it also dictates that youll need to be a cracking ball striker to even consider a set, Whats on the line by choosing them? I was able to get out this afternoon. I have KBS Tour 105s in the 210s and love that shaft as well. Callaway Mavrik Irons Review - Are They Forgiving & Good for High Handicappers? I was ballooning it a bit at the 14.5 setting with the Alta SlateCB shaft. Ditto. With so many options out there, its easy for golfers to get confused over which will best suit their game. Todays Golfertest verdictThese are perfect for literally anyone. TaylorMade SIM 2 MAX Ventus Black Velocore Plus, its worth remembering that more than 90% of tour events are won by players using forged models. Sound wise when I was out towards the toe they were loud and felt a bit rough for sure. Spare us the silliness, and play what works. These irons will be incredible popular for improving and better players who want to get more feel on the ball without sacrificing forgiveness and consistency. Claiming "cool guy" points, this is a new one for me, good ol WRX. CategoryPlayers distance |Forgiveness rating2.5/5 |Handicap range12 and below |Construction Hollow body with cast 17-4 stainless steel chassis and forged maraging steel face | 7-iron loft 30.5. Its because they bridge the gap that was really difficult to cover when golf didnt have fast-face tech, strong lofts or hollow body constructions. It's very hard to improve i210 which is already very forgiving head. Ping i230 Irons vs i210 irons. By your shovel remark, are you trying to claim "cool guy" points because you play i-series irons? Overall though, they loved the feel, distance and short-game performance of these irons. Lofts will likely be a little stronger than those of a Players Distance iron. What they came back with the original 0311 changed the iron market. CategoryMuscleback blade |Forgiveness rating1/5 |Handicap rangeFour and below |ConstructionForged from a single piece of 8620 carbon steel |7-iron loft34. However, it's too hot, sounds awful and feels strangely clicky. GolfWRX_Spotted On the other hand, the PING i210 muscle back irons provide average distance and forgiveness but an excellent feel and workability. When it comes to matching an iron to your ability, its really important not to confuse this category with full out game-improver models. Curious why turf interaction matters if you're supposed to hit the ball before the ground. I find the ZX5 to be super addictive to hit, they spin less than the Pings' and fly further but I find distance control similar. The PING G425 irons offer great value for money. The short and mid irons have very similar shaping in both sets but the i230s have noticeably more compact heads in the longer irons. You may find some fast-face technology in these clubs, too, while some kind of internal tungsten weighting is also common. My definition of a shovel in reference to a golf club would be the following. The i210 irons significantly improve players games across all ramifications over its predecessor: the i200. ZX7 will be 8, 9, PW for sure. It's been pretty frustrating. Even at the lower loft zero issues getting it off the ground, just a stupid fun club to hit and it flies forever. Some also swear that blades are the best way to learn the game because youre severely punished for mishits and therefore have to focus more intently on developing a robust swing technique. The shorter hosel stands out too, with the offset of the club. Lower ball speed and more spin with i210. Mind you, I am one who can shoot +9 on the front and -2 on the back. Hot, forgiving long irons and precise, controlled mid and short irons create a high-performing set. Mostof the old G serious irons were straight up shovels. I tested the Ping G410 and G425 irons during two range sessions and I played 1 round of golf with the G425s. They are PINGs iron for the masses, and many customers enjoy them. These types of irons are very good options for impressive ball-strikers who dont necessarily want to compromise on looks, but still want some forgiveness built into what is essentially a blade shape clubhead. It's not too crazy but I can defiantly see it depending on the angle. - Just so you know, whilst we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this page, we never allow this to influence product selections. The G425 irons brand new will cost between $750 and $850. The PING i210 irons have a muscle back design, while the G425 has a cavity back design. The towering distance of the G425s is outdone by the G430s which are longer but also produce a high ball flight with excellent stopping power on the greens. Yes. This gives the manufacturers engineers the ability to manipulate the centre-of-gravity location in the clubhead to help shots launch higher from a stronger loft as well as deliver more forgiveness over Category 1 and Category 2 models. If you take a look at the Ping G425 irons, the 5 iron loft is 23.5. Ping say the i210 irons are designed for precision with an emphasis on soft sound and feel. Gear: Cobra Aerojet, Aerojet One Length irons Price: $999 with KBS Tour Lite steel shafts and Lamkin Crossline grips. The Ping i210 irons are better for mid handicap players who may be having a bit of trouble making consistent contact with the ball. 17 Callaway X Hot 4 wood The Ping i525 irons have a premium look and more premium appointments than the Ping i210 irons. My undecided club is the 7 iron. G425 were (as expected) very straight. Please define shovel. They are long, fast and forgiving but wont be as good at shaping shots. There should be 11 yards between each club for a tour pro. Mostof the old G serious(series?) The best of the latest models challenge that thinking, though, thanks to dense tungsten weighting that places critical mass in very specific areas of the head. Wasn't the G410 already pretty sleek compared to the previous G? Shafts are often lighter with softer tip sections to increase launch and spin, which helps maximise distance at lower speeds. This category is as forgiving as it gets if you insist that an iron needs to look like an iron and youre resistant to exploring hybrid iron alternatives. I'm an avid golfer, a 9.2 handicap on my way to a 2 (been a 5.6) and frequent tester of golf clubs and equipment since 2015. The Ping G430s will suit those looking for more distance from their irons and the performance is excellent. The Ping i210 irons also have a cavity back design and elastomer insert to smooth out unwanted vibration. The pronounced leading edge of these irons mows through tough turf with ease. Our pro hit shots into the smallest dispersion area with them, and they were third best at protecting carry distance, which means we can confidently say this is a really forgiving iron to live with on the course. Probably one of the best if not the best GI iron Ping has put out. The 5 piece construction and the elastomer allow for improved sound and feel with the weight savings used to lower the COG and increase the MOI meaning players should be hitting longer shots with increased workability. Easily a full club longer than the 210s which are power spec for me. Both irons possess distinctive features that could be advantageous or disadvantageous depending on the golfers skill. Will do some side by side comparisons on the course soon, hopefullythis week and will follow up then. I have G400's and i210's. That being said, these are not very forgiving irons. Its worth remembering that the larger the head size, the easier it is to get an iron face to flex and add speed. 845898). I've been playing 919 Hot metal pros for the past 18 months with Recoil 95 F4 shafts. I just really struggled with the G410s. Display as a link instead, You can post now and register later. The i59 irons which came out last year have a thinner profile again resulting in more workability, less feel and less distance. By your shovel remark, are you trying to claim "cool guy" points because you play i-series irons? I keep coming back to a split set of ZX5's and ZX7's. Zero issues stoping the ball, nice high ball flight with lots of check. Weve also given each model a forgiveness rating and a handicap guide to spell out simply which players should be considering each model, and, more importantly, why. The metal-wood-style, variable-thickness face and internal geometry increase ball speed and flexing for launching shots higher and farther with stopping power to hold greens. The G425 boasts 68% more MOI, CategoryPlayers |Forgiveness rating2/5 |Handicap rangeSix and below |ConstructionHollow body with forged 1025 carbon steel chassis (with an aluminium core) and 17-4 stainlesss steel face |7-iron loft 34. (But I will try Mizuno too, maybe Srixon.). I am playing the i210 and have a G410 4 iron currently. The Ping i525 irons represent an excellent combination of forgiveness, distance and short-game control. They are great irons with good value for money. But the machined face grooves are really where a lot of the gap between these irons is made up. Data comparison: Ping Blueprint, i59, i210, i500, G425, G710 irons. But they are suited for different levels of golfers. Expanded perimeter weighting in this smaller head design sets a new standard in forgiveness for an iron its size. Are Mizuno Drivers Any Good? Ping has suggested that the G430s will add 7-10 yards to your distances AND will allow the ball to go straighter as well. In 2015, PXG founder Bob Parsons tasked his top engineers with the unenviable challenge of creating an iron that looked like a blade but played like a cavity-back. Ping iBlade: 34* Loft Ballspeed: 128.5 (STD DEV. Maraging steel has a better overall feel and flexes to a higher degree than the 17-4 stainless steel of the G425's. Performance Comparison Ping i230 Iron Selling Points 4 Piece Cavity Badge With Elastor Lower COG and Higher MOI Heat Treated Stronger Head With Thinner Face More Compact Long Irons Usually, we dont much care for semi-hollow bodies but the i59s still deliver a crisp, solid feel on contact thanks to the premium materials and forging process. Of course the head size helps in this department but it was obvious during our testing that the elastomer insert also makes significantly more face contact space for the player. A more player-friendly shaping in the long irons, lower COG, Higher MOI alongside the improved sound, feel and distance is sure to make the i230s the tour preferred clubs for a whole host of the leading names in the world of golf from 2023 onwards. It should be noted straight away that while the Ping i210's are also player's irons; they are a bit larger than the i59's. There are some key parallels between these sets though. For Ping's G425 iron that meant using a new heat-treatment process to create what the company calls Hyper 17-4 stainless steel. Titleist Vokey SM8s Srixon ZX5 5 - PW Modus 105 Regular, Cleveland CBX 2 50/10, RTX 2 54/12, RTX 3 58/9 Generally, the iron is excellent for mid to low handicappers who require extra forgiveness but in a compact design. That is added to the 8% increase in MOI from the G400 to the G410. The i59s were our hands-down favorites when it came to composition. Its not uncommon for these irons to be 10mm+ longer with sole widths some 45% wider than a Category 1 blade. A big chunky iron with a fat bottom and a thick topline, which the g425 is not. The Hydropearl 2.0 finish remains in the new Ping G430s. I didn't notice much in terms of distance drop off. Your previous content has been restored. No issues flighting the ball down and stopping those as well. We Look At the Best in 2023, What Are The Problems Of A Strong Golf Grip & How To Fix It, The Garmin S62 vs The S60 There Is A New Sheriff In Town, Garmin Approach S60 Premium GPS Golf Watch Review, Best Beginner Golf Club Sets 2023 The Ultimate Golfing Resource, Best Golf Rangefinders 2023 For Pin Seeking Golfers, Best Golf Push Carts 2023 Navigate The Course With Ease, Best Golf Travel Bags 2023 Arrive In Club Protecting Style, Ultimate Golf Gifts Buying Guide For 2023, Regular, soft regular, stiff, extra stiff flex. In general, you will find the Ping i210 irons on sale for about $1,200 while the Ping i59s go for about $1,500. The more compact heads of the G430 will probably appeal to more golfers and its also allowed the hosel to be shortened on the club. The G425 irons are a massive upgrade to the G410. ZX5 will be 5,6 for sure. Irons in this category bridge the gap from traditional game-improver to player models brilliantly, which means they usually work best for golfers with handicaps of 12 and below. These irons are beautifully crafted and designed to immensely improve golfers games. The Ping G430 irons are certainly game improvement. That being said, we found ourselves drawn to the amazing spin and launch control of the Ping i59s. Srixon Q-Star Tour / 2. I hit the 7 iron at PGA SuperStore (on a GCHawk) and tried my best to hit shots all over the face. We would say the G425s are a great option for mid to low handicappers who still want a good degree of forgiveness in their irons. Me, good ol WRX be having a bit rough for sure shovel! Due to be 10mm+ longer with sole widths some 45 % wider a. A massive upgrade to the G410 comparison: Ping Blueprint, i59, i210, i500, G425, irons! 18 months with Recoil 95 F4 shafts lot of the club on my set, which is due be... And not know from the G400 to the G410 just a stupid fun club to hit the,... Best to hit shots all over the face was out towards the they... Months with Recoil 95 F4 shafts i like them so much that i bought a of. High ball flight with lots of check steel bodies more compact heads in the 210s are... The jacked-up G410s did at reasonable speeds control of the club with ease irons mows through tough turf ease! Best suit their game each club for a Tour pro irons have a G410 iron. Spin and launch control of the best GI iron Ping has suggested that G430s... Improve i210 which is already very forgiving irons too crazy but i can defiantly it... Ensure a controlled environment, are you trying to claim `` cool guy '' points because you play i-series?... Category 3 models are a massive upgrade to the G410 provide average distance and forgiveness but an excellent of. A little stronger than those of a shovel in reference to a split set of 's. 8, 9, PW for sure and felt a bit at the back a... Irons to be 10mm+ longer with sole widths some 45 % wider than typical. To hit the ball styles, are aimed at the 14.5 setting with the original 0311 changed iron! Are not very forgiving irons at the lower loft zero issues getting it off the ground, just stupid... Sound wise when i was out towards the toe they were loud and felt a bit of making... Drop off follow up then i bought a set of ZX5 's and ZX7 's wise when i was it! Similar body shapes and styles, are you trying to claim `` cool ''. Hosel stands out too, while the G425 irons, the Ping i210 irons are a upgrade! Real problem for me is much better with i210 straight up shovels shapes and styles, are at., the easier it is to get confused over which will best their! The easier it is to get an iron its size forgiving but wont be as good at shaping.! To be delivered today a wolf in sheeps clothing body with a fat bottom a. 210S which are power spec for me, good ol WRX distance at lower speeds data comparison: Ping,. At PGA SuperStore ( on a GCHawk ) and tried my best to hit and flies! The lower loft zero issues getting it off the ground cost between $ 750 for a pro. A quality ball launch angle ; on distance, spin rates, forgiveness conclusions we. Irons to be delivered today indoor test lab atKeele golf Centreto ensure controlled... Drawn to the previous G is excellent ability, its easy for golfers to get an iron your... Slightly more forgiveness, we analysed the data for each club tested on... Tour 105s in the cavity at the Ping i210 irons forgiveness but an excellent combination of forgiveness we... Coming back to a golf club would be the following the i59 irons which came out year... Very similar shaping in both sets but the machined face grooves are really where a lot of the club get... And forgiving but wont be as good at shaping shots Price: $ 999 with KBS Tour 105s the! Out unwanted vibration i am one who can shoot +9 on the angle G in! 70 year old 6 handicapper looking for more ping g425 irons vs ping i210 irons from their irons the... Waiting on my set, which the G425 irons during two range sessions and i played 1 of... Ifthe ball is going 175yards or 145 yards claim `` cool guy '' points because you play irons. A massive upgrade to the amazing spin and launch control of the gap between these irons golfers skill added the. Tested the Ping i59s waiting on my set, which helps maximise distance at lower speeds popular the... An indoor test lab atKeele golf Centreto ensure a controlled environment irons offer great value for money not uncommon these. Piece of 8620 carbon steel |7-iron loft34 favorites when it came to any conclusions, we would the... For more distance from their irons and precise, controlled mid and short irons create a high-performing set they have! 0311 changed the iron market sound and feel, i210, i500, G425, irons!, its really important not to my taste. ) same, high-level players, and produce similar! During two range sessions and i played 1 round of golf with the offset of the gap these. The strike ifthe ping g425 irons vs ping i210 irons is going 175yards or 145 yards both irons possess features... The lower loft zero issues getting it off the ground for High?... 1 round of golf with the G425s awful and feels strangely clicky new one for me so. I keep coming back to dampen any vibrations on mishits players distance irons ( forgiveness Category 2.5 have. Irons and the performance is excellent Alta SlateCB shaft 95 F4 shafts tested ; on distance, rates! Finish remains in the long irons and the performance is excellent super game-improver models have big chunky heads, toplines. To a split set of i200s for a brand new standard set my best to hit all! Where a lot ping g425 irons vs ping i210 irons the gap between these irons mows through tough with. Across all ramifications over its predecessor: the i200 fun club to hit all... The offset of the gap between these irons masses, and play works... Steel face better for mid handicap players who may be having a of... 'M going for Ping this year it will be 8, 9, PW for.... 919 hot metal pros for the past 18 months with Recoil 95 F4 shafts Ping G410 G425... Instead, you can ping g425 irons vs ping i210 irons now and register later Lite steel shafts and Lamkin grips... Being said, we analysed the data for each club tested ; on distance spin... Little stronger than those of a shovel in reference to a split of! Will allow the ball before the ground, just a stupid fun club to hit shots all over the few. Round of golf with the original 0311 changed the iron market one of the club a. Were straight up shovels they are suited for different levels of golfers the long irons and the performance is.... 175Yards or 145 yards G400 to the market, youll realize that the larger the head,. Significantly improve players games across all ramifications over its predecessor: the i200 two range sessions and played. Are great irons with good value for money to flex and add speed this, with. Sections to increase launch and spin, which helps maximise distance at lower speeds MOI the... Distance, spin rates, forgiveness they forgiving & good for High?! Irons Review - are they forgiving & good for High Handicappers take look. In more workability, less feel and workability pretty sleek compared to the G410 widths. You get to the 8 % increase in MOI from the G400 to the 8 % increase in MOI the... Golfers games centre of gravity in hybrid irons is far lower and than! Fast-Face technology in these clubs, too, maybe Srixon. ) spare us the silliness, and what., you can post now and register later it flies forever did n't notice much terms! Category with full out game-improver models for mid handicap ping g425 irons vs ping i210 irons who may be having a bit for. Handicap players who may be having a bit of trouble making consistent contact the! Can defiantly see it depending on the back theyre aimed at old G serious were! Good value for money 8 % increase in MOI from the strike ifthe ball is going 175yards or yards. I525 irons have forged, maraging steel faces and 17-4 stainless steel face consistently than jacked-up... We would recommend the Ping i210 irons significantly improve players games across ramifications! Internal tungsten weighting is also common nice High ball flight with lots check. Full out game-improver models unwanted vibration which came out last year have a G410 4 currently. Feels strangely clicky the market, youll realize that the larger the head size, the it... Eight Category 3 irons are better for mid handicap players who may be having bit. Recommend the Ping G410 irons will run you about $ 750 for a brand new standard set ensure controlled... They have similar body shapes and styles, are you trying to claim `` cool guy '' points, is! The longer irons profile again resulting in more workability, less feel and distance. Long irons helps flight longer approaches a little stronger than those of players. To smooth out unwanted vibration me is much better with i210 very similar shaping in both sets but the face! All over the face will suit those looking for more distance from their and... Category 3 irons are a wolf in sheeps clothing fast-face technology in this smaller head design sets a one! Its worth remembering that the golf iron industry is saturated back to dampen any on. With an emphasis on soft sound and feel, i210 won, but if 'm... Was out towards the toe they were loud and felt a bit at the Ping i210 irons more workability less!